Good questions. Helpful humans.
Mythical Pizza questions and answers
Your first visit should feel like discovering a new favorite, not decoding an ancient map. Start here, then ask the Mythical Crew about anything still hiding in the fog.
Ordering and visiting
Follow the trail
These answers cover the questions guests ask most often about the menu, ordering, delivery, dietary choices, events and visiting the restaurant.
How can I place a Mythical Pizza order?
For the quickest, most accurate experience, order at an in-store kiosk, through Toast for pickup or delivery, or through DoorDash for pickup or delivery. Because every Mythical Pizza can include so many custom choices, we do not take phone orders. Digital ordering lets you review every detail and confirm pricing before the order goes directly to the kitchen. A crew member will happily help you order in store.
It is my first visit. Where should I start?
Come hungry and tell us what you love. Choose a signature pie, start with a Baby Squonk, Lil' Mothman or Daddy Bigfoot build-your-own, or ask a Mythical Crew Member to help create something completely original. Classic is wonderful. Weird is welcome.
Can someone help me customize my food?
Absolutely. A crew member can explain the sauces, cheeses, proteins, vegetables, crusts, stuffed edges and finishes, help you find a favorite and guide you through the in-store kiosk.
Do you offer delivery?
Yes. Choose Toast for rewards, coupons, scheduling, pickup or delivery through DoorDash Drive. You can also order directly through DoorDash.
Does Mythical Pizza deliver to my town?
Delivery availability depends on the delivery address, current driver coverage, and ordering platform. Enter your address in Toast or DoorDash to see whether delivery is currently available and to review the estimated time and fee before checkout.
How do Mythical Rewards and Toast coupons work?
Sign in or order through Toast to earn and use eligible Mythical Rewards and apply current Toast coupons. Review the offer details, eligible items, dates and minimum purchase before checkout.
Can you accommodate allergies or dietary needs?
The menu includes gluten-friendly, keto-friendly, meatless and vegan choices, but the kitchen is not allergen-free and cross-contact is possible. Please tell a crew member about every allergy before ordering so we can explain ingredients and shared preparation areas.
Does gluten-friendly mean allergen-free?
No. Gluten-friendly describes available menu choices, but Mythical Pizza is not an allergen-free kitchen. Shared equipment and preparation areas are used, and cross-contact is possible. Review our dietary and allergy guidance and speak with the crew before ordering.
Where can I find deals and current menu prices?
Our Deals page lists current promotions and Toast coupons. Toast is the source for current menu prices, customization charges, availability, and sold-out items.
How do pizzas cook so quickly?
After a pizza is prepared, specialty impingement ovens use carefully controlled high heat and moving air to flash-fire it in roughly three to four minutes.
Who helps if something is not right with my order?
For an in-store kiosk or Toast pickup issue, call 304-402-6984 with the order name and details. For a DoorDash pickup or delivery issue, contact DoorDash support at 855-431-0459, since DoorDash manages those orders from checkout through delivery.
Can Mythical Pizza feed my event?
Yes. Weddings, birthdays, corporate gatherings, employee outings, school events, church groups, reunions, showers and game days are all welcome. Explore Mythical Pizza catering, or use regular ordering for groups of fewer than 10.
Where is Mythical Pizza and when is it open?
Visit 1855 Valley Road, Suite 200, Berkeley Springs, WV 25411. We are open Monday through Wednesday from 11:30AM to 9PM and Thursday through Saturday from 11:30AM to 10PM. We are closed Sunday. Get directions and plan your visit.
Still tracking down an answer?
Visit the restaurant and ask a Mythical Crew Member. We are happy to help you order with confidence.
Hours and directions