MYTHICAL MORSELS (STARTERS)

WENDIGO'S WICKED GARLIC WHIRLS

JERSEY DEVIL JALAPEÑO JOLTS

FLATWOOD MONSTER FINGERS

YETI'S YUMMY CHICKEN PARM PORTIONS

CHUPACABRA CHEESESTEAK CHUNKS

SASQUATCH SPUDS

BABY-MOTHMAN'S 7" PIZZA

Starting At: $8.50

YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY.

Starting At: $13.00

THE MOTHMAN STRIKES BACK

WYLD SHAGGYNS

E.T. THE EXTRA TOPPINGS SUPREME

FLATWOOD BUELLER'S DAY OFF

BALSAMIC STRIPES

POULTRYGEIST

SMOKEY AND THE BIGFOOT

SPROUT-MAN AND THE MASTERS
OF THE PIZZERIA

A KRAMPUS STORY

A NIGHTMARE ON BRAXIE STREET

QUADZILLA KING OF PEPPERONI

DOUGH OPTIONS

CRYPTID CLASSIC CRUST

SASQUATCH STUFFED CRUST

+$4.00/PIZZA

MOTHMAN'S PEPPERONI & CHEESE ROLL STUFFED CRUST

+$5.00/PIZZA

SQUONK'S BACON & CHEESE STUFFED CRUST

+$5.00/PIZZA

CRUSTLESS PIZZA (IN A BOWL)

12" GLUTEN-FRIENDLY CRUST

+$3.50/PIZZA

10" FATTYHEAD KETO CRUST

+$6.00/PIZZA

FLAVORED EDGE FINISHES

LOCH NESS GARLIC EDGE

+$1.00/PIZZA

HYDRA FLAMIN' HOT CHEETO EDGE

+$1.00/PIZZA

CHIMERA COOL RANCH EDGE

+$1.00/PIZZA

BUNYIP BLUE TAKI EDGE

+$1.00/PIZZA

FINISH YOUR PIZZA WITH A TOUCH OF DRIZZLE OR A DASH OF SPICE

SUPERNATURAL SIDES

SKINWALKER SLIM ROLL

MOTHMAN'S PEPPERONI ROLL

THE HODAG MONSTER ROLL

THUNDERBIRD ROLL

GARLIC BREAD

CHEESY GARLIC BREAD

LARGE GARLIC BREAD

$11.00 (13")

LARGE CHEESY GARLIC BREAD

$12.00 (13")

BABY NESSIE'S PERSONAL SALAD

Starting At: $8.50

YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY.

Starting At: $13.00

WEIRD SHEEPSQUATCH

SPECTERMOOSE

RISKY BIGFOOT

GROUNDBUSTERS

THE NEVERENDING SALAD

CRYPTID DESSERTS

CHOCOLATE CHIP CANNOLI

$4.00 EACH or 3/$10.00

SLICE OF CHEESECAKE

$3.50 EACH or 2/$6.00

CHOCOLATE CHIP BROWNIE

$3.50 EACH or 3/$9.00

MONSTER COOKIES

$3.00 EACH or 3/$8.00

MINI-MONSTER COOKIES

$1.50 EACH or 6/$8.00

REESE'S MONSTER COOKIES

$3.00 EACH or 3/$8.00

BOTTLED PEPSI PRODUCTS

16.9 OZ DASANI PURIFIED WATER

APPLE & EVE JUICE BOXES

2 LITER PEPSI PRODUCTS

CRYPTID CLUB SODAS

BRAVE BARISTA COFFEE

12oz $2.00 | 16oz $2.75

VISIT Us TODAY

With fresh ingredients being prepped daily, we're here to serve our local community with flash-fired pizza for the masses!

Visit our location at:
1855 VALLEY ROAD, SUITE #200
BERKELEY SPRINGS, WV 25411

OUR MYTHICAL MENU

STARTERS

PIZZAS

SIDES

SALADS

DESSERTS

DRINKS

MYTHICAL INGREDIENTS, LEGENDARY PIZZAS

MYTHICAL MORSELS (STARTERS)

Discover the magic of six savory bites, each a masterpiece of tender chicken and rich mozzarella cheese, lovingly enveloped in our signature fresh dough. Baked to perfection, these portions offer a symphony of taste and texture in every bite. Paired with a marinara dipper. Add bacon for $1.00 more!

CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA

YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY. FULL SIZED PIZZAS STARTING AT $13.00*

Is our CRYPTID CLASSIC CRAFT PIZZA too big for you? NO PROBLEM! The solution is our Baby-Mothman's Personal 7" Pizza! This three topping pizza is sure to fulfill your hunger pains and get you back into the action!

You're in complete control! Start from your choice of crust base, select from 8 different sauces, 7 types of cheese, over 20 different toppings and over 10 types of finishing touches to make it truly YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY.

A Long Time Ago, In A Galaxy Near Point Pleasant... Classic Marinara Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage & Fresh Spinach, Drizzled with Tangy Barbecue.

We believe our adventure through time has taken a most serious turn! Classic Marinara Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Pepperoni, Sausage, Diced Tomato & Dill Pickles

The best adventure on Earth! Classic Marinara Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers & Black Olives

How could I possibly be expected to handle school on a day like this? Classic Marinara Base, Ham, Pineapple and Jalapeño Peppers! A simply sweet and spicy treat for everyone. *BOWP BOWP* Ohhh yeaaah!

The story of a Mothman who wanted to keep the world safe...and eat pizza! A unique twist on a Caprese Salad! Classic Marinara Base, Fresh Mozzarella±, Diced Tomatoes & Spinach. Drizzled with stripes of Balsamic Glaze.

THEY'RE HEEEEERE! Buffalo Sauce Base, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken±, Banana Peppers & Jalapeño Peppers, Drizzled with a Ranch.

This "Smokey" Masterpiece is Bigfoot's Favorite Pizza! Barbecue Sauce Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken±, Bacon±, Green Peppers and Corn. Finished with a Barbecue Drizzle!

BY THE POWER OF BRUSSELS SPROUTS! This delicious pizza is adorned with a Garlic Oil Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Feta Crumbles, Red Onion, Bacon± and our Garlic Roasted Brussels Sprouts±, then drizzled with our delicious Balsamic Glaze! YOU HAVE THE POWER!

He Sees You When He's Creeping! Garlic Oil Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta±, Steak Crumbles±, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Red Onions, Sprinkled with Italian Seasoning.

Whatever You Do, Don't Fall Asleep! Parmesan Alfredo Sauce Base, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta±, Bacon Crumbles±, White Meat Chicken± & Fresh Spinach, Drizzled with Honey Sriracha.

QUADZILLA IS ATTACKING!! Classic Marinara Base & SUPER MEGA PEPPERONI (that's eighty slices of pepperoni) for a fully encompassing, mouth watering experience! It's then finished with a dusting of fine ground spicy red chili pepper and drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey±!

*Any STANDARD Toppings Included. PREMIUM and XTRA Toppings are a $1.25 up-charge.SUPER MEGA PEPPERONI is a $3.00 up-charge.

DOUGH OPTIONS

CRYPTID CLASSIC CRUST OPTIONS

Elevate your pizza experience with our tantalizing Cheese Stuffed Crust. Unveil a realm of savory indulgence as you venture beyond the ordinary. Immerse yourself in the mysterious allure of every bite, where our signature dough embraces a hidden treasure trove of melted cheese!

Immerse your taste buds in the rich and savory experience as you bite into the perfectly baked crust, revealing gooey melted cheese and premium pepperoni slices nestled within. Crafted to perfection, this stuffed crust pays homage to West Virginia's Pepperoni Rolls!

Uniting the timeless allure of crispy bacon and melted cheese, this culinary masterpiece features a rich stuffed crust. Savor each bite as the smoky aroma of bacon intertwines with the creamy embrace of melted mozzarella cheese, creating a taste that's impossible to resist!

UNIQUE CRUST (and CRUSTLESS) OPTIONS

Trying to cut back on carbs? Try your MYTHICAL PIZZA in a 9" bowl! We'll fill your bowl with DOUBLE of all of your selected delicious ingredients and flash-fire it for awesomeness! That's 2X the cheese, 2X the meat and 2X the veggies for 100X the awesomeness!

Our 12" GLUTEN-FRIENDLY CRUST is free from wheat, dairy, and nut allergens and is suitable for those with Celiac disease and those who follow a vegan diet. This crust delivers a crispy, chewy crust that serves as the perfect base for your MYTHICAL PIZZA!

Are you on KETO? This amazingly delicious FATTYHEAD crust is made with Mozzarella Cheese, Cream Cheese, Eggs, Almond Flour, Flax Seed, Salt, and Herbs. You'll FLIP over the fact that our 10" FATTYHEAD KETO crust has only 4g net carbs per pizza crust. WOW!!

ADD A FLAVORED EDGE FOR MAXIMUM MYTHICALITY

FLAVORED EDGE FINISHES

We finish the edge of your pizza in rich flavors of garlic and aged Parmesan cheese. Each bite delivers a tantalizing blend of garlic perfectly balanced with grated Parmesan.

Spice things up! We pulverize CHEETOS® Crunchy FLAMIN’ HOT® for an amazingly cheesy and blazing finish to you pizza! The team will finish the edge of your pizza with garlic oil and a thick dusting of the snacking treat!

Let us finish the edge of your pizza with the bold and unique flavors that you crave! We drizzle your edge with garlic oil and apply a thick dusting of DORITOS® COOL RANCH®!

Looking for a tantalizing uniquely blue and scorching finish to your pizza edge? Look no further! We'll coat your edge in garlic oil and finish your pizza's edge in Takis® Blue Heat crumbles of chili that makes you feel the warmth of pepper in your mouth with every bite.

MAKE IT TOAAAAASTED FOR NO EXTRA CHARGE!

SUPER SAUCES

CHEESY CHEESES

MOUNTAINS OF MEAT

VITALIZING VEGGIES

FINISH YOUR PIZZA WITH A TOUCH OF DRIZZLE OR A DASH OF SPICE

SPICY CHOICE:SPICY BUFFALOHONEY SRIRACHATANGY BARBECUE

SAVORY CHOICE:CREAMY RANCHBALSAMIC GLAZE

FINISHING SPICES:COARSE SEA SALTITALIAN SEASONINGFINE SPICY RED CHILI DUSTING

FANTASTIC FINISH:CLASSIC PESTO FINISH*NEW* MIKE'S HOT HONEY± ($1.50 DRIZZLE or $1.50 DIP CUP)

ORDER A KIDZ MEAL FOR THE LITTLES!

BABY BIGFOOT KIDZ MEAL$9.007" 2-Topping PizzaMini Cookie

BABY SQUONK KIDZ MEAL$6.004" 1-Topping PizzaApple & Eve JuiceMini Cookie

SUPERNATURAL SIDES

PIZZA ROLLErZZZ

The West Virginia staple now has a Cryptid Twist! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a pile of Pepperoni and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, and then baked to a golden brown, and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!

A mixture of Wisconsin and West Virginia twists! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a carnivore treat, including Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, then baked and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!

SASQUATCH SATISFIERS

The tangy, delicious garlic bread is made with our savory garlic oil, topped with our parmesan-parsley and garlic blend, and served with our Classic Marinara!

Want to take your garlic bread up a super notch? Let us smother it with mozzarella shreds and bake it in our flash-fire oven for that warm gooey cheese! Paired with a marinara dipper.

Our classic garlic bread, without cheese, in a larger format for any hunger! This delicious garlic bread is made with our savory garlic oil, topped with our parmesan-parsley and garlic blend, and paired with a marinara dipper.

Make it a LARGE one! This one is a MYTHICAL PIZZA Fan Favorite! We take your garlic bread up a notch with mozzarella shreds and bake it in our flash-fire oven for that warm gooey cheese! Paired with a marinara dipper.

CREATE YOUR OWN SALAD

YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY.HUGE SALADS STARTING AT $13.00*

CRYPTID CRISP SALADS

A smaller approach to our HUGE salads! Start with our Lettuce Blend and then top it with the ingredients to support your personalized appetite! Served with choice of dressing packet (additional dressing packets available for an upcharge)!

Build yourself a custom salad from scratch! All of our HUGE SALADS come in a 64 ounce bowl, and loaded with your choice of toppings!

So, What Would You Little Maniacs Like To Do First? Our take on a Greek Salad. Lettuce Blend, Feta Crumbles, Cherry Tomato, Green Peppers, Red Onion & Black Olives.

Don't Say His Name Three Times! Lettuce Blend, Cherry Tomato, Green Peppers, Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Red Onion, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Jalapeño Peppers, Sweet Corn & Mozzarella Shreds.

There's A Time For Hiding In Place And A Time For...Risky Bigfoot! Lettuce Blend, Cherry Tomato, Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Mozzarella Shreds & White Meat Chicken±, Served Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing.

We Came! We Saw! We Ate Some Salad! Lettuce Blend, Cherry Tomato, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Cheddar Shreds, Ham & White Meat Chicken±.

HEY YOU GUUUUYS! Lettuce Blend, Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Dill Pickles, Feta Crumbles, White Meat Chicken± & Steak Crumbles± - Sorry, no BABY RUTH'S on this pizza!

Every real salad is a never ending salad! Lettuce Blend, Cherry Tomato, Green Peppers, Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Red Onion, Black Olives, Sweet Corn, Cheddar Shreds, Bacon Crumbles± & White Meat Chicken±.

*Any STANDARD Toppings Included. PREMIUM and XTRA Toppings are a $1.25 up-charge.

CRYPTID DESSERTS

Our cannolis are out of this world! Our shells have a light, flaky consistency that complements our delicious cream, which is combined with citron pieces, chocolate chips, vanilla, and cinnamon for a sweet, traditional flavor.

Our cheesecake has a rich, velvety smooth consistency! Each cheesecake is made with soft cheese, eggs, and sugar in the famous New York style of cheesecakes with a light graham cracker crust. Top it off for an additional $0.50!

These decadent brownies are the best ending to any meal! These brownies feature a dense, fudgy texture, and are topped with sweet chocolate morsels for the ultimate chocolate flavor rush!

Nothing says "CRYPTID LOVE" like a freshly baked cookie! All of our HUGE 1/4 LB. MONSTER cookies are baked fresh in house every day! We always have chocolate chip, but check with us for any specialty flavors we may have!

YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY.
FULL SIZED PIZZAS STARTING AT $13.00 *

How could I possibly be expected to handle school on a day like this? Classic Marinara Base, Ham, Pineapple and Jalapeño Peppers! A simply sweet and spicy treat for everyone. BOWP BOWP Ohhh yeaaah!

*Any STANDARD Toppings Included. PREMIUM and XTRA Toppings are a $1.25 up-charge.
SUPER MEGA PEPPERONI is a $3.00 up-charge.

SPICY CHOICE:
SPICY BUFFALO

HONEY SRIRACHA

TANGY BARBECUE

SAVORY CHOICE:
CREAMY RANCH

BALSAMIC GLAZE

FINISHING SPICES:
COARSE SEA SALT

ITALIAN SEASONING

FINE SPICY RED CHILI DUSTING

FANTASTIC FINISH:
CLASSIC PESTO FINISH

NEW MIKE'S HOT HONEY± ($1.50 DRIZZLE or $1.50 DIP CUP)

BABY BIGFOOT KIDZ MEAL
$9.00

7" 2-Topping Pizza
Mini Cookie

BABY SQUONK KIDZ MEAL
$6.00

4" 1-Topping Pizza
Apple & Eve Juice
Mini Cookie

YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY.
HUGE SALADS STARTING AT $13.00 *

No added sugar and 100% of the day's vitamin C in a juice box? If you won't tell the kids, we won't either. Gluten free, Kosher, Pasteurized, Non GMO Project verified.

Flavors include:
- Apple
- Very Berry
- Fruit Punch

(304) 402-MYTH

OPEN MON-WED : 11:30AM - 9PM
OPEN THU-SAT : 11:30AM - 10PM
CLOSED SUNDAY