Mythical ingredients. Legendary choices.

Pizza menu in Berkeley Springs

Start with a signature legend or build something no one has seen before. The menu also brings wings, starters, salads, pasta bowls and desserts to the table.

View live prices and order Printable menu

Find your favorite

Every craving has a creature

Prices and availability can change, so Toast is the source for current pricing and sold-out items. Tell the Mythical Crew about allergies before ordering.

Signature pies

Legends with a head start

Meet Quadzilla, E.T. Supreme, Nightmare on Braxie Street, Alabama White Thang, Alfredo vs. Predator and more cryptid-approved combinations.

Explore every signature pizza →

Build your own

Your pizza. Your legend.

Choose a Baby Squonk, Lil' Mothman or Daddy Bigfoot, then add sauces, cheeses, proteins, vegetables, specialty crusts, stuffed edges and finishing moves.

See the custom pizza options →

Wings and starters

Release the appetizers

Batsquatch Wings, Paranormal Pretzels, Mozzarella Monster bites, Cryptid Rolls and bold sauces make sharing optional.

Browse wings and starters →

Salads and pasta

Big bowls. Bigger flavor.

Build a Baby Nessie or Mama Nessie's Salad, hunt down a Kraken's Noodle Bowl or choose a pasta creation with your favorite sauce, cheese and protein.

Browse salads and pasta →

Sweet legends

Save room for sightings

Monster cookies, cheesecake, tiramisu, cannoli and seasonal desserts are waiting at the end of the trail.

Explore desserts →

More than pizza

Breakers and seasonal finds

Discover loaded Breaker sandwiches and limited-time Fall and Winter favorites alongside the full Mythical lineup.

See what is available today →

Search by craving

Use this guide to find a starting point, then open Toast for current prices, availability, and every customization.

Build your own pizza

Baby Squonk: 5-inch, 2-cut personal pizza.

Lil' Mothman: 10-inch, 4-cut pizza.

Daddy Bigfoot: 14-inch, 8-cut hand-stretched pizza.

Signature pizza legends

Mozzarella Monster, Yeti's Pepperoni Pie, Quadzilla: King of Pepperoni, E.T. Extra-Toppings Supreme, A Nightmare on Braxie Street, The Princess Brine, and Close Encounters.

Wings, salads, and pasta

Batsquatch Wings, Baby Nessie, Mama Nessie's Salad, Build Your Own Noodle Bowl, Beast of Busco Bowl, Red-Eyed Inferno Bowl, and more.

Desserts and Monster Cookies

Monster Chocolate Chip Cookie, Monster S'more Cookie, Monster Box, Mothman Tiramisu, seasonal cheesecake, cannoli, and Wendigo's gluten-friendly peanut butter cup pie.

Menu questions

What pizza sizes does Mythical Pizza offer?

Build-your-own pizzas begin with the 5-inch Baby Squonk, the 10-inch Lil' Mothman, or the 14-inch Daddy Bigfoot. Signature pizzas are full-size creations. Toast shows current sizes, prices, and availability.

Does Mythical Pizza have gluten-friendly and keto-friendly choices?

Yes. Choices may include gluten-friendly cauliflower crust, Fattyhead Keto Crust, Keto Bowls, and selected gluten-friendly desserts. The kitchen is not allergen-free and cross-contact is possible. Review dietary and allergy guidance before ordering.

Can I order pizza for pickup or delivery?

Yes. Toast offers pickup or delivery, rewards, coupons, and scheduling. DoorDash also offers pickup or delivery. Enter your address to see current delivery availability.

Where should I check current menu prices?

Use Toast for current prices, availability, sold-out items, and customization details. The printable and website menus are helpful guides, but prices and availability may change.

Dine in, take out or deliver

1855 Valley Road, Suite 200
Berkeley Springs, WV 25411

Open Monday through Wednesday, 11:30AM to 9PM, and Thursday through Saturday, 11:30AM to 10PM. Closed Sunday.

Choose how to order Hours and directions →