The purpose behind the pizza

More than a pizza shop

Mythical Pizza is a family-owned, faith-guided Berkeley Springs restaurant created to serve people, strengthen community and turn an ordinary meal into a story worth telling.

Who we are

A legendary meal with a local heart

We believe food should be fun, hospitality should feel genuine and business should leave a community stronger than it found it.

We prepare dough in-house, prep fresh vegetables daily, choose quality ingredients and flash-fire every pizza for a fast, flavorful result. A huge range of sauces, cheeses, proteins, vegetables, crusts and finishes gives every guest the freedom to build exactly what they crave.

The cryptids make the experience unforgettable, but the people give it meaning. We welcome first-time visitors, regulars, families, travelers and adventurous eaters with the same goal: help every guest feel cared for and excited to come back.

Quality without shortcuts

Prepared dough, fresh daily prep and food we are proud to put on the table.

Freedom to create

Classic, adventurous, meatless, keto-friendly, gluten-friendly, stuffed, drizzled or completely original.

People come first

Guests, crew members, neighbors and community partners deserve dignity, kindness and genuine care.

Faithful community impact

Christian faith guides how we steward resources, support local causes and serve our community.

Pizza Marketplace 2026 Top 100 Movers and Shakers award

National recognition

Top 100 in the nationProudly local

Pizza Marketplace ranked Mythical Pizza #42 on its 2026 Top 100 Movers & Shakers list. The restaurant has also earned Best of the Best recognition in 2023, 2024 and 2025.

See every award and source

Legends lift legends

Community is part of the recipe

Success means serving our community well, lifting local organizations, celebrating young people, supporting first responders and creating meaningful opportunities for the Mythical Crew.

Schools and youth

Celebrate hard work

Student recognition and community partnerships help encourage education, attendance and positive growth.

Request community support →

Local organizations

Raise some dough

Eligible schools, churches, teams, nonprofits and community groups can host an approved fundraiser.

Explore fundraisers →

Our crew

Grow together

We support individual strengths, build skills, laugh together and create room for people to grow.

Join the crew →

Come experience the legend

Find us at 1855 Valley Road, Suite 200 in Berkeley Springs, West Virginia.

Hours and directions