Recognition earned. Gratitude shared.

Top 100 in the nation.
Proudly local.

Every award begins with a crew that cares, guests who keep coming back, and a community willing to believe in a wonderfully weird pizza place.

National recognition

#42 among the 2026 Top 100 Movers & Shakers

Pizza Marketplace placed Mythical Pizza at #42 on its 2026 national list. For one independent pizzeria, that is one mighty footprint.

Pizza Marketplace 2026 Top 100 Movers and Shakers recognition

A national spotlight on a local legend

The honor recognizes momentum, originality, and the people shaping the pizza industry. We are proud to represent our crew, our customers, and the community that gave the legend room to grow.

View the Top 100 source

Hometown honors and trusted recommendations

The legend keeps growing

Follow each link to the organization that published the award or recommendation.

Best of the Best Readers' Choice Awards 2025

Best of the Best 2025

Readers' Choice recognition from The Journal.

Best of the Best 2024

A second year of hometown support.

Best of the Best 2023

The first of three consecutive honors.

Best Pizza 2026

Recognition published by Restaurant Guru.

RestaurantJi Recommended

A recommendation backed by guest feedback.

Taste what the fuss is about

Come hungry. Leave legendary.

Find Mythical Pizza at 1855 Valley Road, Suite 200, Berkeley Springs, WV 25411.

Choose how to order Plan your visit →

Top 100 in the nation.Proudly local.